Just wanted to share the list I piloted to Rank 2 (currently 4) this month. First of all, all the credit belongs to Magnnarot, as he created the deck and I just tuned it slightly to my liking. I found the deck to have a ton of versatility in how it can win games and the key to success being figuring it which gameplan to take in order to secure the win.
Notes on changes:-I removed the two Auric Interrogators for two more Varas. I didn’t trigger the draw effect enough and dying to torch is not ideal on a 3 drop. I loved the 4 Vara build.
The other change I made was putting a Vanquish in the market instead of Plate. I got 2 for 1’d by Equivocate, Annihilate, etc too often with plate and I rarely wanted to spend 5 power to play it except late game. Vanquish was awesome. Turn 3 Merchant into turn 4 Vanquish your Titan or Vara was a huge swing.
The best card in the deck (and maybe in the meta overall) was the Display. I never was unhappy to see it and deciding when to use it to recur units and when to use it to kill a big opponent’s unit is perhaps the biggest determinant of success with the deck. I even won a handful of games using the “third” effect.
My biggest question mark is probably Vanquisher’s Blade, as it sometimes just ended the game when thrown on something like Tavrod and killing a HOTV, but at other times was a dead card. It’s another hit for Tavrod as well which is important (especially without Interrogator) but hitting on a Tavrod draw doesn’t make or break the deck either. The other card I question is Gavel in the market. It just completely hoses some decks and is great against opposing Display of Ambitions, but far too often I wish it had been anything else-like even a Blinkwolf.
Anyway, I’ve played this deck more or less exclusively in Ranked over the past two weeks and think I’ve gotten pretty good with it. I’m seeing a lot of lines that aren’t obvious right away and doing a nice job figuring out my best plan for winning the game based on matchup and game state once the mid game arrives, which has lead to a lot of victories in games that seemed up for grabs. I’d be happy to answer any questions and again, Magnnarot deserves the credit for the deck. It’s a beast.
If you feel like changing the gavel, I'd suggest Urn of Choking Embers if you want something more reactive against HH, other charging decks and aegis in general. Some other good cards to play with your market are: Bandit Queen, Obliterate and Vicious Highwayman. All in all, I have now moved away from the Hidden Road Smuggler and have been making the deck more and more aggressive since its first iteration, but there is plenty of space to experiment with the archetype.